Cereal blogs and consumers tested out Carmella Creeper when it dropped in July. On Instagram, @snackolator said the cereal tasted like “caramel apple.” It’s a bit subtle on the flavor, but I like that because, as you eat more and more handfuls, it really is the right amount of flavor,” they wrote. The Impulse Buy felt similar about the flavor’s strength. “[When consumed with milk], the sweet and fruity flavors were less noticeable.”
A relatively new cereal, it only has five reviews on Amazon. As of this writing, it has four five-star reviews and one two-star review, which states the cereal tastes like its designer “had never had caramels or apple.” Another enjoyed it, comparing it to Apple Jacks.
Carmella Creeper and her cereal also appear in The Monster Mash, which was released at the same time. Its box is designed with every monster past and present, including Carmella Creeper, Count Chocula, Franken Berry, Boo Berry, Fruity Yummy Mummy, and Fruit Brute.
Static Media owns and operates Mashed and Daily Meal.