Howlett said that he highly recommends using the Peanut Butter and Strawberry Jam Sandwich Uncrustables for the best results. “I was never a big fan of strawberry — I love the grape — but the strawberry mixed with that butter? Oh my God, it’s so good,” he admitted. The former college athlete explained in a TikTok video you then create your French Toast batter as you normally would by mixing together milk, some vanilla extract, and ground cinnamon in a bowl.
Next, dip your Uncrustables in the batter and coat each side of it before adding it to a skillet that’s covered in butter. Let it cook for a bit on each side until it looks golden brown and then take it off the heat and let it sit for a minute. Howlett divulged that after he was finished making the late-night treat he devoured it all. “I finished both way too fast and I’m going to make some more,” he said. “Try it out please!”