Scoring 44% against four other options is a pretty impressive win for Crunchy Brownie Oreos; still, not every voter thought they were the best choice. One commenter said, “The crunchy brownie flavor is enticing but we’ve got enough chocolate flavors. Another fruity flavor would be refreshing…” They were on the right track; the second-place winner was Strawberry with 30%. Seeing such enthusiasm for fruit-flavored Oreos is interesting, given that there’s only one fruit flavor currently listed on the brand’s website: lemon.
Two unique flavors tied for third place; Peach Oolong and Sakura Matcha Oreos each raked in 10% of the votes. Both of these flavors hit China’s shelves in 2020 but have yet to make their way to the States. As for last place, that title goes to Chestnut Oreos; only 6% of voters went for this flavor, but one commenter said, “This poll shows you never had brown butter fried chestnuts.” While they may have been the least popular option in the poll, Chestnut Oreos could perhaps succeed in the U.S. as a seasonal holiday flavor. Plenty of folks in the comments suggested other ideas or mentioned flavors U.S. Oreo fans do have that they love. Ultimately, though, as one fan wisely commented, “Nothing beats the original.”