Costco’s returning pumpkin cheesecake certainly does sound “dangerous,” but in all the right ways. It features a buttery graham cracker crust filled with pumpkin cheesecake filling, a layer of spiced cream, and whipped cream. It also comes pre-cut with 16 slices, each of which Instagram user @costcohotfinds called “the perfect amount” last year. Unfortunately, no price information has yet been shared, but since last year’s retailed for $17.99, customers can likely expect to shell out a similar amount in 2023.
The dessert has been making its annual holiday season appearance for several years now, and if you’ve yet to pick it up for yourself (it is pretty heavy, after all), you may be wondering if it’s worth the hype. Based on reviews from other Costco shoppers, it certainly seems to be.
“These are incredible. I could eat the whole thing,” one Redditor said last year, while the year prior, another user claimed it was the winner of their Thanksgiving meal. “I drizzle chocolate sauce all over it,” u/everybodyBnicepls shared. “Next level, I tell ya.” Several Costco members have also said the pumpkin cheesecake freezes well, so if you spot it in your local store, you could easily pick up a second one to keep in your freezer, just in case you start craving a taste of fall long after the season ends.